Game Pass, PS Plus & Co. or Buy a Key?
Renting access or owning a licence: a decision guide without price maths
GameHalla Redaktion · Updated
A subscription pays off when you play lots of different games for a short time. A key pays off when you play one game for a long time or keep coming back to it. Many players are best served by a mix.
The difference: access for a while or a licence you keep
A subscription such as Xbox Game Pass or PlayStation Plus gives you access to a catalogue. You can play as long as the subscription runs and the game stays in the catalogue. When either ends, the game stops launching.
A key buys you a licence for one game. Once redeemed, it stays in your Steam, PlayStation, Xbox or Nintendo library. Our guide How does a game key work? explains the redemption.
Save games usually survive the end of a subscription. They sit in the cloud or on your console and carry over if you buy the game later. Check this for the specific game if it matters to you.
The subscriptions at a glance
Providers change tiers and content regularly. The table shows the basic idea; details are on the official pages.
| Subscription | Tiers | What you get |
|---|---|---|
| Xbox Game Pass | Essential, Premium, Ultimate, PC Game Pass | Console online multiplayer from Essential, a larger catalogue per tier; new games at launch with Ultimate and PC Game Pass |
| PlayStation Plus | Essential, Extra, Premium | Online multiplayer and monthly games from Essential, game catalogue from Extra, classics and game trials with Premium |
| EA Play | EA Play, EA Play Pro | Catalogue of EA games, trials of new releases, discount on EA purchases; Pro adds new games early and premium editions |
| Ubisoft+ | Classics, Premium | Classics: catalogue of older Ubisoft games; Premium: also new releases at launch and premium editions |
| Nintendo Switch Online | Standard, + Expansion Pack | Online play and classic game collections; the Expansion Pack adds more classic consoles and selected DLC |
Some subscriptions are bundled: EA Play comes with Game Pass Ultimate and PC Game Pass, Ubisoft+ Classics with Game Pass Ultimate and PlayStation Plus Extra and Premium.
When a subscription pays off
- You play many different games and finish them within a few weeks.
- You want to try genres or series without risking money on a purchase.
- You want new releases at launch and your tier includes them on day one (for example Game Pass Ultimate, PC Game Pass or Ubisoft+ Premium).
- You need the online subscription on console anyway and use the catalogue on the side.
- Your friends have the same subscription and your group switches games often.
A quick reality check: how many catalogue games did you actually play over the last few months? If the answer is one, you are paying for a catalogue you barely use.
When a key pays off
- You play a game for years, such as a builder, an RPG you replay or a multiplayer title.
- The game is not in any catalogue, or it is leaving soon. Games rotate out, usually with short notice.
- You mainly play on PC via Steam, where most games have no subscription option.
- You want to play offline without a subscription check.
- The game has been out for a while and keys cost noticeably less than at launch.
Comparing prices is worth it for older games in particular. GameHalla lists offers by platform: PC, PlayStation, Xbox and Nintendo.
Combining both
Subscriptions and keys work well together. These approaches hold up in practice:
- Take one month of a subscription, finish a specific game, then cancel. For short games that is often cheaper than buying.
- Try a game in the subscription. If you want to keep playing long term, buy a key later and continue with your save.
- Before a game leaves the catalogue, check the member discount. Game Pass and EA Play offer discounts on selected games, depending on the tier.
- Only keep the subscription in months with several releases you care about, and cancel it in quiet months.
Subscriptions are also sold as codes. See Redeem an Xbox code and Redeem a PlayStation code.
Checklist for your decision
- How long will you play the game? Weeks point to a subscription, years to a purchase.
- Is the game in your tier’s catalogue, and for how long?
- Do you need an online subscription on your console anyway?
- How many other catalogue games would you play in the same period?
- Is the key cheap right now? A look at the price comparison takes a minute.
- For new releases: is it worth waiting for reviews? See Preorder or wait?.
Frequently asked questions
Do I keep games from Game Pass or PS Plus?
No. You can play them while your subscription is active and the game is in the catalogue. To keep a game, you have to buy it, for example as a key. Save data usually stays.
Do I still need a subscription for a console key I bought?
Not to play it. For online multiplayer, PlayStation, Xbox and Nintendo require a subscription such as PS Plus Essential, Game Pass Essential or Nintendo Switch Online in most paid games. Many free-to-play games are exempt.
Is EA Play included in Game Pass?
Yes, in Game Pass Ultimate and PC Game Pass. Ubisoft+ Classics is included in Game Pass Ultimate and in PlayStation Plus Extra and Premium. Bundles change from time to time, so check the official page.
Can I buy subscriptions as keys or codes?
Yes. Codes for Game Pass, PlayStation Plus and Nintendo Switch Online are sold by retailers too. Make sure the code’s region matches your account region.
Is a subscription worth it on PC?
You do not need a subscription to play online on PC. PC Game Pass, EA Play or Ubisoft+ make sense there if you play a lot of games from those publishers. For single Steam games, a key is usually simpler.



